Editorial
Dear readers,
'Drushti Stree Adhayan Prabodhan Kendra'
functions in Pune. The center deals with women related studies,
awareness and awakening, research regarding women's issues,
collection of women related news and respective publications.
All of you must have gone through the
first issue of Mahila Vishwa 2005. It is with great pleasure
that we present the second issue which is based on the major
events regarding women during the year 2006. Besides the available
information, we have also included certain articles written
by experts in the filed of women's studies. Drushti collects
the information from various newspapers, government reports
& the projects undertaken by various social institutions.
The information is categorized according to subject. After
each 2 months, a collection of special news, articles and
reports is done on the basis of the respective issues. In
2006, one could see that the media discussed a lot about dance
bars, PNDT Act, Female Foeticide, women in military and Marriage
Registration Act. Mahila Vishwa 2006 contains articles based
on these issues.
There is an effort to make the people
from the various strata of society aware of these subjects,
make them give a thought to these issues and also make them
take a serious note of the same. Female foeticide was discussed
on a very large scale in the year 2006. Since this issue affects
the social life directly, it has been presented from the social,
administrative and the medical perspective.
In addition to this women who have received
various awards or have completed commendable tasks have also
been specifically mentioned. During the last year, besides
regularly compiling news, Drushti studied and analyzed the
migration of the girls who go for domestic work from Adivasi
areas from Jarkhand, Orissa and Chhatisgad to Delhi. 200 girls
from this area were surveyed. These girls are brought to Punjab,
Delhi, Mumbai & Goa for domestic work. The agencies which
give jobs to these girls and the social workers in this field
were also interviewed and a major social problem was studied.
Through this study, Drushti tried to seek social attention
to the problems of the girls from Adivasi areas. A booklet
based on this is also being prepared. In this age of information
explosion, the workers of Drushti have very studiously and
meticulously selected only the proper and relevant information.
Our special thanks to Mr. Shailendra
Borkar from Sanwad Trade Prints for making this issue a very
presentable one. We also thank the advertisers who have always
been helping us.
It is the result of the collective efforts
of the various people that we are in a position to present
this issue of Mahila Vishwa. We hope that it will be certainly
useful for you. Your suggestions are always welcome.
Dailies like Sakal, Loksatta, Maharashtra
Times, Lokmat, Navbharat Times, Pudhari, The Indian Express
& The Times of India were referred to frequently while
writing the articles or while writing about the major events
or happenings during the year 2006.
Anjali Deshpande
Secretary
Editorial Committee -
Asha Bapat
Swati Lele
Ranjana Khare
Neelakshi Godbole
Contents
About ' Drushti '
It is essential to think about women's
development and progress while thinking about the social change.
Women have a lion's share in social development. However,
due to patriarchal cultural and social conditions as a result
of it, women were oppressed. Many problems like injustice
to women, violence to women, their economic, educational backwardness
the question of their exploitation arose.
With the aim of studying women's problems from all angles
and to make the society aware of them and to make efforts
to solve these problems, Drushti Stri Adhyan Kendra was established
in 1996.
Various programs undertaken by Drushti - Collection of women
related news an articles published in news papers and magazines
since 1996 is available. Collection of reports of women's
commission as well as booklets regarding women's problems
are also available.
Study Circles - (1) Feminism (2) Hindu thought regarding women
(3) Holistic views on women (4) Act against domestic violence
& right to property by heredity.
Seminars - (1) Informal education of women during post independence
era. (2) Effects of T.V. serials on family life.
Published Works - (1) Informal education of women during post
independence era. (2) Statistics related to women's issues
for India and the world. (3) Bimonthly collection of news.
(4) Women's health (5) Women's social development through
self health groups in Maharashtra.
Survey - (1) Problems of domestic workers. (2) Health of teenagers.
(3) Women's social development through self health groups
in Maharashtra. (4) The study of the problems of migrated
girls from Zarkhand, Chattishgad and Orissa in search of jobs
in Delhi. Report of the same has been published.
Trustee Board
1) Smt. Nirmala Vaidya - Chairperson
2) Smt. Anjali Deshpande - Secretary
3) Smt. Sunila Sovani - Treasurer
Members
1) Smt. Pramila Medhe
2) Smt. Geeta Gunde
3) Smt. Pushpa Nade
4) Smt. Ranjana Karandikar
5) Smt. Suvarna Rawal
6) Smt. Nirmala Apte
7) Smt. Nishigandha Mogal
8) Smt. Geeta Gokhale
Foeticide
: Measures at administrative level
By Dr. Chandakkar
In 2006 media discussed foeticide on
a very large scale. The major reason for such a discussion
was the very low birth rate of the female child as compared
to that of the male child in India. Foeticide and female infanticide
have been growing rapidly and have affected our social life
& the consequences of such a growth have become very conspicuous
by now. Its a very agonizing picture and a matter of serious
concern. Therefore from various strata of society efforts
are being made to eradicate the problem.
Even the government is also looking
into the matter seriously. A detailed information regarding
the administrative majors taken by the Health Department of
Pune Municipal Corporation to prohibit foeticide was sought
from Dr. Dhananjay Chandakkar.
In 2003 the government amended the old
PNDT Act and prohibition of Sex Selection Act was passed.
Resultantly, government could considerably control the process
of identification of sex of a foetus. Previously there was
no control over private medical practitioners and so, female
foeticide was rampant since sex identification of the foetus
was rampant. But according to the new law it is mandatory
for every such medical practitioner to register himself as
gynecologist or radiologist. So, sonography machine cannot
be bought in the absence of such a registration. Registration
makes it obligatory for the medical practitioner to submit
a monthly report of the abortions done. The report has to
be submitted to the advisory committee of the Health Department
of the PMC. The PMC has appointed an advisory committee for
the implementation of this act. The committee consists of
a gynecologist, an advocate for PMC, woman representative
or women empowerment officer and a representative of an NGO.
After each 3 months scrutiny of the professional's work is
done. The law also has a provision for punishment. The task
is carried out under the observation of 14 ward medical officers.
The report by this committee includes the information regarding
whether a particular abortion is done after the first female
child or the second female child. A meeting of the committee
is held after each two months and all the registrations are
scrutinized, complaints are dealt with and legal advises given.
Illegal practitioners or people advertising
such illegal matters can be sued to the court under this act.
The committee has assertively stated
that due to this act male-female birth rate ratio has shown
a positive change. In order to create awakening regarding
foeticide, PMC has undertaken Janeev Jagruti Mission. The
PMC in collaboration with IMA also conducted a programme called
curb the menace of sex determination.
PMC has also prepared an exhibition
concerning the subject and last year in the Anganwadi Sevika
Meet, a detailed information of foeticide was given. Similarly
doctors from Ashtang Ayurveda and Tarachand Hospital were
informed about the act and awareness was created.
Dr. Chandakkar expects common citizens,
doctors and NGOs to participate in this mission. He also appeals
to the NGOs to help in taking action against illegal medical
practitioners.
Foeticide : A medical perspective
Dr. Vaijayantee Khanvilkar
In the 21st century India has progressed
rapidly in the filed of science. However, incidents which
bring disgrace to the whole humanity have also been taking
place. In the various states of India, either in rural or
urban regions, a female child is killed after it is born or
in some cases people see to it that a female child is not
born at all and therefore, they exploit science and kill the
female foetus.
According to Lanset, a magazine published
from Britan, it is reported that in India within just a span
of 20 years one crore female foeticide cases have taken place.
This means that the average is 5 lakhs foeticides. The nobel
prize winner economist Amartya Sen has observed and pointed
out that total female population of the world is 10 crore
less than the male population of the world. The reducing no
of girls is very evident from the census statistics. The awareness
of the fact that the reduced number of women is to produce
disastrous effects for the society has laid to making efforts
at social awaken of all the strata of society.
" Female foeticide must be
a serious concern for doctors also, otherwise the social health
will face dire consequences," asserts Dr. Khanvilkar
the PNDT (Pre Natal Diagnostic Technique - Regulation and
Prevention of misuse Act 1994) was implemented. The basic
purpose of the act was to control sex determination by foetus
test. This test legalized abortion in case of the diagnosis
of hereditary disease or incase of genetic problems. But the
loop hole of this law was once the genes were known, diagnosis
of sex naturally followed it. Therefore, to avoid this sought
of sex determination and female foeticide based on that PNDT
had to come into being. To examine or diagnose hereditary
disease, improper growth of the foetus, level of Hb or any
psychological problem of the mother, the act made a provision
for the use of prenatal diagnostic techniques. But unfortunately
this technique was exploited for sex determination before
delivery and female foeticide if the foetus was that of a
female child.
Scientist develop an easy, convenient,
visual and multidimensional technique called ultrasonography.
It became available easily everywhere and due to it sex determination
became easy. Female foeticide started taking place on a large
scale, once the sex was determined easily. During last two
decades sonography has been used as an equipment for female
foeticide and this has resulted into the dangerous reduction
of the number of females.
In case of an unwanted pregnancy, according
to MTP law 1991 abortion is allowed till first 20 weeks. However,
this law was exploited to the advantage of some and sex determination
and abortion within 18 to 20 weeks became a business for some
doctors. If one studies the census report, it is evident that
:
Year Women Men
1901 972 1000
1981 933 1000
1991 927 1000
2001 922 1000
This means that even with the increase
in literacy rate, the birth rate of girls has been lowering
and the sex ratio is not at all stable. Surprisingly even
in the case of economic affluence and availability of medical
facilities, the percentage of women is less than men. This
certainly means that craze for having a son and therefore
striving for a son is not at all a passed but very much a
present reality.
Sonography is beneficial but it should
be used for proper reasons.
1] If an experienced doctor does sonography
then the diagnosis can be proper or perfect. But unfortunately
there are sonography centers in small villages or district
places where untrained, unqualified professionals diagnose
the case on a very superficial level.
2] Since abortion is legal in India female
foeticide is done on a very large scale.
3] The proportion between registered
sonographists and the number of sonograhpy machines is inverse.
It is very obvious that many untrained persons learned the
technique only at a superficial level and determine the sex
of the foetus and foeticide takes place based on this diagnosis.
Another fact related to this become evident that illegal sonography
centers and the companies which sell these machines have formed
a large racket. As a result of this, women have to suffer
in this way :-
1. Frequent abortions lead to deterioration
of health.
2. Frequent abortions affect women psychologically.
3. Mental tension causes difficulty in delivery.
4. Frequent abortions cause economic burden for the family
as abortion is costly. This affects the families mental health.
5. Frequent abortions cause illhealth and tend to be the means
of death also.
It is, therefore, a doctor's duty to
make women understand the seriousness of these effects. If
a women has to maintain her health and a family has to retain
economic stability then abortion must be thought as something
wrong as small family only can make possible the progress
of all its members. Dr. Khanvilkar stresses that we have to
be alert if we want to stop sex determination and foeticide.
A woman has a right over her body. So she should protest against
abortion. It is necessary that woman becomes powerful and
asserts her opinions strongly. Responsible doctors, knowledgeable
citizens and social institutions or NGOs should make efforts
to stop foeticide. For this mission, government, police and
judiciary should also cooperate.
Child's health should be given importance
instead of thinking about whether it is a girl or a boy.
Female Foeticide and the tale
of 21st century Droupadi
Dr. Nishigandha Mogal
The census report of 2001 shows that
there are 927 women after each thousand of men. In Maharashtra
the no of women is only 922. This data made me very restless.
Half of the world population has to be women yet the no of
women is reducing day by day and it has resulted into imbalance
of every sort. One grieves to visualize the condition of women
in future and it is a matter of serious worry.
Blind imitation of the west and the widely
spread utilitarianism have led to the rampant increase in
the no of bear bars, dance bars and sex workers in urban as
well as rural areas. Besides these problems affecting the
society, a tendency to be indifferent to the environmental
or societal problems is also on the rise.
In a poor family, female foeticide takes
place since it is impossible to bring up, educate the female
child or it is very difficult to provide safety to the female
child and pay for the amount of dowry in her marriage. In
an affluent family a son is very much needed to run the family
business and also to retain the enormous wealth with once
own family only.
In fact, obviously, son's position as the light of the family
is the sole responsible factor for the female foeticide. Actually
during the last 5 or 6 decades, a lot of research has been
done. Guaranteed remedies are available even for the most
incurable disease. Mans life span is increased. In such a
situation female foeticide seems to be the reason of the reducing
number of women as compared to men.
In our country after each 10 years head
count is done. Government officials visit each and every house
and register the male and female members of the society. According
to government statistics, 1901 the man women ratio was 1000
: 972, which has changed to 1000 : 927 in the last 100 years.
Due to world wars and invasions by foreigners the number of
men reduce and during 1947, the number of women was bigger
than that of men or it was equal to the that of men. Besides,
a small news in the Indian Express dated 26th September 2002
agonized me more than anything else : what was the news ?
The news was : the ratio between a girl child and boy child
between the age of 0 and 6 was surveyed in Pune, Satara, Kolhapur
& Solapur Districts and it was found out that for every
one thousand boys there were only 850 to 859 girls. This certainly
means that the number of girls is going to be lesser and lesser
by the year 2010. No prophet is needed to state that in the
immediate future this grim and scary situation is to take
a monstrous form.
In 1985, a group was established in order
to oppose amniotic fluid test. Through the medium of this
committee, a movement was initiated so that the government
banned such a diagnosis of a foetus. As a result of the agitation,
by this committee 1988, government introduce a law which prohibited
amniotic fluid test for sex determination. This law also had
a provision for punishment for the ones who broke the law.
However in the so called modern Maharashtra, this law was
introduced in 1994.
Our country is cursed with a tendency
to break laws. Very excellent and effective laws are introduce
but later on effective implementation of these laws does not
take place as the selfish motives of the guardians of law
and compliance of law makers and the antisocial elements make
it a difficult task. And then any desirable law turns into
something meaningless. The same thing was experienced in the
case of this law. The number of sonography centers has been
increasing rapidly not only in cities but also in towns. In
the absence of any moral control upon the law breakers, this
diagnosis is made in not only private but also in government
hospitals, sometimes secretively or sometimes openly. Advertisements
of government - recognized abortion centers are seen every
where and to save five lakhs in the future, it is advised
that one should spend Rs.5000/- for abortion, if the foetus
is a female one. A girl's education is a waste, she will go
to her in-law's house and then how come she is useful ? What's
the use of educating her ? These are the questions asked by
the girl's parents. Besides parents kill female foetus, since
they will have to pay dowry or they feel that in the present
social condition a girl will be exploited oppressed. This
fear and the feeling of insecurity is the main reason for
their behaviour.
Today, in various ways, women are becoming
victims of provoked lust of men as they are exposed to extreme
expression of sex-drive, advertisements of medicine industries
entertaining pornographic desires and also the provocative
programs on various channels. Then what will be the state
of affairs when children who are six or seven years old today
become youth. Imagining such a situation is a nightmarish
experience because women will be a scarcity if there are 150
women less after each 1000 men. In 2001, in Sangli, Satara,
Beed, Solapur, Kolhapur and Aurangabad districts have reported
the existence of 900 girls after each 1000 men. However, only
in Mumbai, the number of women has reduced to 898 from 942.
This is a matter of serious concern. This number will show
a major reduction after 20 years. But in Delhi, Punjab, Rajasthan,
Gujarath, Himachal Pradesh & Jammu Kashmir this number
is only 793 to 878 only. In Rajasthan, there are some places
were no girl exists. The present situation itself is causing
violence against women. Compared to other parts of India,
the situation in South is better as the number of women there
is 948. The number of women is very small and the cases of
female foeticide are rampant not only in India but also in
China, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, East Asia and Egypt. But
America is an exception to this. There are 105 woman after
each 100 men. At world level, the rate is 98 per 100 and in
Europe it is 95 to 97 per 100, i.e. the number of women is
almost equal to the number of men. Some conclusions can be
drawn based on this information : (1) The proportion of women
is comparatively higher in educated areas. (2) Female foeticides
take place more rich or affluent families not only in India
but in all other countries.(3) The percentage of abortions
is more in big cities. (4) The number of abortions has been
increasing with the increasing number of sonography centers.
(5) The number of girls between 0 and 6 years of age is much
more in an inaccessible, illiterate & poverty-stricken
area like Gadchiroli.
My thoughts continued and it bothered
me to think about the future of our society after 20 years
from now. Today itself a mere refusal from a girl results
into her unhesitant murdered or making her look ugly by throwing
acid or at times, she is raped and left to bear death throughout
her life. A bride is burnt if she does not bring the amount
of dowry or does not cater to the various demands on the parts
of the family of her in-laws. Man has become so lusty that
even a female child is raped by relatives in the same villages,
gundas or even teachers. This is done in rural areas as well
as in the interior parts of the country. Of course, we have
been reading about such incidents.
What will be the condition after 20 years
? This is the only thought that has been troubling me :- (1)
Parents of a female child will have to guard there child as
if she were a precious thing (2) There will be a separate
/ distinct police system for women (3) A new problem will
arise and it will be taking dowry from men & their dowry
deaths will take place if dowry is not paid. (4) Many men
will have to remain bachelors due to his situation (5) The
customs regarding arranging the marriage will be revised.
(6) They will be female dominated instead of the previously
male dominated ones. (7) Droupadi had to be a wife of five
husbands. After 20 years, one may see such Droupadies in every
village.
The issue is very serious and only presenting
it before the readers will not be sufficient to solve the
problem. Of course doctor Vimal Mundada took concrete decisions
regarding the relative law as soon as she shouldered the responsibility
of the health ministry. In 2002, she got the amended amniotic
fluid test prohibition bill passed and included new sections
in it :- (1) Advertisements regarding this test and abortion
were banned. (2) Only registered institutions were allowed
to conduct this test and the purchase of ultrasonograhpy machines
was prohibited in the absence of registration. (3) Registration
was made mandatory for retailers who wished to sell these
machines. (4) It was made compulsory for sonography centers
to give detailed information and in order to control illegal
sex-determination a particular software was established at
28565 ultrasound centers. (5) It was made essential that sonologists
before conducting the test of a pregnant woman has to feel
in the ' M form and submit it to the government. ' (6) Besides,
as mentioned earlier, this law does include all the necessary
reasons for the test.
It seems that the mission of social awareness
or education in this regard was done only at a superficial
level just to create government reports. Either the plans
or programmes at the government level do not reach the people
or fake papers reports are produced by those who have been
given concerned responsibilities. It is quite possible that
people do not understand the seriousness of the matter or
the antisocial elements exploit people's ignorance to there
own advantage. Many a time, society or the government is misguided
as these jobs are done in return of a meager amount of money.
This has to be stopped immediately. The implementation of
law should be a reality so that the anti-socials and criminals
are punished. To achieve this result social awareness and
people's education regarding the issue seem to be the only
effective remedies to the problem. This measure must be implemented
vigorously, collectively and ceaselessly on individual as
well as institutional levels.
Violence within the family and
participation of women in decision making
|
State
|
% of women victims of domestic violence
|
% of women participating in decision
making
|
Utterpradesh
Navi Delhi
Andhrapradesh
Arunachalpradesh
Chhatisgarh
Gujarath
Hariyana
Himachalpradesh
J & K
Karnataka
Kerala
M.P.
Maharashtra
Manipur
Meghalaya
Orissa
Punjab
Rajasthan
Tamilnadu
Uttaranchal
West Bangal
Assam |
42.4
16.3
35.2
38.8
30.0
27.6
27.3
6.2
12.6
20.0
16.4
45.8
30.7
43.9
13.1
38.5
25.4
46.3
41.9
27.9
40.3
39.6
|
48.2
69.5
55.7
75.9
51.3
56.7
56.3
52.1
38.9
47.4
62.5
46.7
63.8
85.0
83.4
55.3
52.3
40.2
69.2
47.9
38.1
70.1
|
Awards and
Commendable Work
Snehal More
Award - Kiran Desai gets Booker Award
- Booker, the prestigious award in the field of literature
was conferred upon Kiran Desai, an Indian living in America,
for her novel Inheritance of Loss. She is the youngest author
who has received 50000 pounds as the prize money.
Powerful Woman - The CEO of Pepsico,
MS Indra Nuyi has been declared by Fortune to be the most
powerful business woman of the world. The list also includes
the technical officer of Motorola, Padmashree Warior, again
in Indian.
This ranking is done on the basis of
the share of the business in the world economy, the importance
of quality of the business as well as the concerned women's
career and their effectiveness in the socio-cultural field.
This ranking also includes the president of Boycon, Kiran
Muzumdar - Shaw, Naina Kidwai (HSBC) and Chanda Kochar (ICICI).
Tejaswini Sawant - Tejaswini Sawant
and Awanit Kour Siddhu won gold medal in shooting in the Commonwealth
Games held in Melbourne. Since 1999, Tejaswini got her training
under the guidance of Jaysingrao Kusale. Within a very short
period, she won medals at National and International Levels.
Sunita Williams - A girl of Indian origin,
living in America, Sunita Williams has been selected by NASA
for space travel and she is to live in the space for 6 months.
Sunita was borne on 19th September 1965 in Ohio in America.
She was inspired by Neil Armstrong, the first man to land
on the moon. Sunita has flown for 2770 hours by 30 various
aircrafts. As the flight engineer in the space programme for
6 months, she is to stay in odd conditions and 0 gravity areas.
Lt. Smita Gaikwad - The woman officer
of Military Engineering covered the 250 Sea-miles distance
(Bombay to Goa) in just 2 yachts. The 9 officers courageously
fought against the adverse natural conditions for 100 hrs.
and completed the voyage without any facilities except the
mast.
Dr.Chitra Bharucha - Dr. Chitra Bharucha
was borne in Madurai in Tamilnadu. After completing his MBBS
in Madurai itself, for 20 years, she worked in Northern Island
Blood Transfusion in Britain. In spite of belonging to the
medical field, she was the member of Independent Television
Commission. She was selected to be the president of BBC due
to her knowledge regarding media, their rules and regulations,
news papers, commerce, competition and economic aspect of
all these. BBC is a prestigious and reliable organization
which has a turnover of 4 million dollars and 26000 employees.
One certainly feels proud to have an Indian as President such
an institution.
Girija Devi - An illiterate woman, Girija
Devi from Bhirkhiya Chipulia from Bihar fought against wine.
She was the member of the Panchayat who not only banned wine
shops but also established ' Mushar Vikas Manch ' in 125 villages.
Girija Devi is to present a paper regarding her fight against
wine. This paper will be presented in a conference in women
empowerment section of the UNO.
Mayung Sok - Han Mayung Sok has been
elected the first woman prime minister of South Korea. For
the last 30 years, she has undertaken the cause of women's
rights, environment conservation and protection of democracy.
Mayadevi Sorate - M.S. Mayadevi Sorate
was elected the member of Grampanchayat of Chakur in Latur
dist. She took special efforts to make women's committees
work effectively and actively. She bore the expenses of girls'
education for prohibiting girl dropouts. She started self
help groups and also made attempts for the access of dalits
in various temples. She worked for women's literacy as well
as trained them to voice their opinions and gave them opportunity
to do so. Her mission got recognition at the international
level and she got the opportunity to participate in the 50th
women's status conference organized by UNO in New York. She
will be presenting a paper on the present position of women's
participation in local self governing bodies.
Kiranjeet Kour Matharu - Kiran, a girl
of Indian origin who lives in Britain was attracted to golf,
since her childhood. She won various tournaments even when
she was just an amateur player. She set many records like
Plus 4 handicap. She is number one professional golf player
or Britain.
Anita Kushvaha becomes successful industrialist
- Anita's parents had arranged her marriage when she was just
a child. She refused to marry and also strived for something
that women could not do or that which women were not supposed
to do. She chose honey collection as her business. She started
with 2 bottles but now she manages 100 beehives. She saves
Rs.1 Lakh every year. UNICEF has selected her to be an Ideal
girl. In spite of her birth in a backward family, Anita has
become an ideal daughter who offered economic stability to
her family through her business while continuing her studies
on her own.
Registration of marriage for social
health
Neelakshi Godbole
On 14th Feb 2006, the bench consisting
of Justice Arijeet Pasayat and Justice H. Kapadia implemented
the very important Marriage Registration Act. According to
this act, it is compulsory for the person of any caste, creed
or religion to register marriage. The law which is applicable
all over India has two expected results. (1) Safeguarding
women's rights and their security and abolishing women's exploitation.
(2) This should result regarding women of all castes, creeds
or religions so that it will result into a step ahead of Saman
Nagari Kayada ( Common Civil Code ).
Considering the changing social structure,
women should get more and more safety. The decision of registering
any marriage is certainly commendable as it will stop women's
deception when getting married and raise their status. It
is observed that in the absence of such a law, women's exploitation
has proved to be easy.
The law has made the registration of
marriage compulsory all over the country and irrespective
of the persons cast, creed or religion. It is necessary that
within the first 3 months of marriage, marriage should be
registered. This law is directed towards registration and
concerned matters. The law does not aim at interfering with
personal law. All marriages will take place according to the
traditions and customs of relative religions. Resultantly,
there is no question regarding apposing the act or protesting
against the act.
Once the possibility of opposition to
any law on the basis of religion which is a part of social
reality, is abolished, men and women will be willing to understand
the benefits of the same.
Benefits of Registration of Marriage
:
1] This law will prevent child marriage
as age has to be mentioned while registering a marriage. [2]
Deception and sell of girls under the pretext of marriage
will be controlled. [3] It will not be possible to compel
a girl to marry without her consent. [4] This law will enable
the implementation of law against bigamy. It will not be possible
to have 2 marriages due to his registration. [5] The law demands
that everything which is given to the bride has to be registered
at the local police station and registrar, marriage registration
office. As a result of this, after the death of the husband,
a woman's right to her husband's property will be intact.
[6] A marriage can be declared invalid and a woman's economic
right in case of divorce also shall be preserved. [7] Difficulties
or problems in case of divorce will be reduced. [8] A bill
concerning HIV is to be passed and it also includes compulsory
registration of marriage.
A woman's wellbeing is to be sought
due to these points in the law. This law was applicable to
Maharashtra, Gujarat, Himachal, Karnataka and Goa but its
effective implementation was not a reality.
Passport, pension, women's appeal for
income, divorce and changing the name of a working woman were
the reasons for registering a marriage but every marriage
was not registered. In cities, in spite of literacy, due to
careless and in rural areas, due to illiteracy, ignorance
the percentage of registration was low. Today also there is
no change in it. Therefore, it is necessary to implement this
new law effectively.
Registration of marriage is mandatory
in Christian and Parsi Societies. Muslims also have such a
tradition since long. But these matters form a part of religious
law. Marriage takes place before Kazi. It is registered after
seeking the signatures of the concerned people. However, if
marriage registration is a legal demand, then divorce, second
marriage and problems like these will be reduced.
The most crucial question before a Muslim
woman is divorce and survival after divorce and a single man
marrying many women. Marriage registration is necessary to
solve this problem. The well being of Muslim women lies in
registration of marriage.
By law, it is compulsory for all Indians
to register marriage. So, it is compulsory also for Muslims.
This is to benefit the Muslim woman. Muslim thinkers have
welcomed the decision and have put forward certain points
to make us think.
(1) On the basis of Sheriyat, Muslims
are allowed to have four wives only if the first wife permits.
Many men marry without this consent due to registration of
marriage, it will not be possible for men to marry second
time by deception and it will also be known how many men have
married second time. (2) A Muslim man is reluctant while paying
meher after divorce or Kazis also misappropriate the amount.
But as this amount is registered while registering the marriage,
it will certainly avoid deception or cheating of women. (3)
It will become compulsory to pay the compensation of the Iddat
in the span of 3 months and 10 days after divorce. Women can
insist upon such a payment on the basis of law. This view
was expressed in Panchjanya by the Muslim leader Muzaffar
Hussain.
Solace for NRI women due to Marriage Registration Act
In 2006, the Human Rights Commission
and Foreign Embassy published a booklet regarding marriage
registration. It contents the directives also and it was specifically
published for NRIs and PIOS. This booklet contains various
remedies for the Indian girls who realize their deception
when they go to a foreign country after their marriage. These
girls also face economic, psychological and physical oppression.
In order to safeguard their interests,
the court has suggested legal majors which have these major
provisions : (1) The court in any other country is not entitled
to deny or cancel the marriage of NRI man and Indian woman
which has taken place in India. (2) The act has a provision
to provide economic right to women on the basis of her husband's
wealth. (3) The result given by the Indian Courts will be
binding on courts in foreign. For this, amiable relationship
with other countries will be certainly useful. This can be
brought into practice according to the Civil Procedure Code
section 4 A.
All the women's organizations, voluntary organizations of
NRI and PIOS have welcomed the law which maintains the social
health or order by strengthening the institution of marriage.
This law which provides equal rights
to all Indian women should be immediately and compulsorily
implemented. For this, the procedure of registration of marriage
should be made more and more simpler. Besides the urban population,
social organizations, women's organizations and government
should create awareness among rural population also. This
is compulsory like the registration of birth and death. This
only will lead to the prohibition of women's exploitation
or oppression and they will gain their just rights.
Laws like this one are useful for equality before law and
creation of a society which preserves the rights of all. This
law is a landmark in the process of offering rights to women
by stopping their oppression.
How is a marriage registered ?
A marriage can be registered under the
Bombay Marriage Act. A certificate by priest, father or a
Kazi has to be submitted. Husband and Wife's full name, residential
address have to be mentioned and a proof regarding residential
address has to be submitted. These forms are available in
a weeding hall also. If the marriage registrar's office has
been informed one month prior to the weeding, then the officers
register the marriage in the wedding hall itself. This facilitates
marriage and its registration. It is our duty to shoulder
this beneficial responsibility since we are the aware and
educated citizens.
Indian women are politically more
empowered than the women in America
According to the World Economic Forum
Report, Indian women are politically empowered on a large
scale than the women in the developed countries like America,
Japan, France. However, in spite of the empowerment of Indian
women, there participation in the fields like the economic,
health and higher education is pathetic and India stands at
a very low position as compared to other countries.
In the survey of 115 countries, India
stands at the 20th position regarding participation in the
political field and the important posts held in this field.
Sweden, Norway, Finland and Iceland are at the top position
and Saudi Arabia and Yemen are at the last position.
According to this report, no country
has been able to eradicate sex based disparity. If one considers
how many women in a particular country have become financially
able then among 115 countries India is at the 110 position.
If health is concerned then women from
Norway & Sweden and especially pregnant women have benefited
with good facilities. This includes salaried, maternity leave,
death rate and the available best medical service at the time
of delivery.
Significant Decisions
Ranjana Khare
Government to implement the law effectively
in order to prohibit child marriage - In India, due to poverty
and social traditions, Girls are married at a very early age.
According to the 2001 census report, 3 lakh girls below 15
years have become the mothers of 1 child. 35 % women have
married within the age between 15 and 18. However the Child
Marriage Prohibition Act has a provision to allow the girl
to break the marriage or even not to be labeled as a divorcee
if the girl is below 10 years of age and does not approve
of the same.
According to this law, it is mandatory
for the priest to know whether the bride and bridegroom are
major or not and if he performs the rites of minor's marriage,
then, he will be sentenced to imprisonment for 2 years and
fined Rs.1 Lakh. Also the relatives, parents and friends who
are present for the ceremony can also be punished.
Facilities : Government of Hariyana has
declared 2006 to be the year for girls - (1) If a second daughter
is born then for consecutive five years, the government will
invest Rs.5,000/- in Kisan Vikas Patra in the name of the
daughter & resultantly, at her age of 18, her parents
will get a sum of Rs.86,927/-. (2) Couples having only daughters
will get after their 55 years of age Rs.300/- monthly under
the Ladli Security Scheme. (3) S.C. parents will get Rs.500/-
under the Indira Gandhi Priyadarshani Vivah Shagun Scheme
at the time of their daughter's marriage. Widows below poverty
line will also be benefited by this. (4) 2 % discount will
be given on the registration of property. (5) 33 % reservation
will be provided for the post of school teachers. (6) In ITI
and Technical Institutions also there will be 25 % reservation
for girls. The topper girls in MBA, MCA, IIT and Engineering
will get Rs.5,100/-. (7) There will be 33 % reservation in
buildings built by housing board. (8) Electric Bill in the
name of a woman will get 10 paisa discount per unit. (9) There
will be special discount in bus pass.
Only woman not responsible in extra-marital
relationships : decides National Commission for Women - a
woman involved in extra marital relationship can not only
be held responsible or declared guilty. According to the law,
she will be treated as a victim. The national commission for
women rejected the provision that even women should be charged
guilty in matters regarding extra-marital relationship. The
commission has also recommended that extra-marital relationship
should not be treated as criminal offence. However it should
be interpreted as a social ill. Of course, the commission
has stated that this should be implemented only after seeking
the approval all over the country. A woman who has extra-marital
relationship is also a particular kind of oppressed person
and therefore only an action should be taken against her as
per the section.
The commission has also recommended that
CPC sec 198 (2) should be amended. Resultantly, a wife will
get right to take legal action against her husband who follows
extra-marital relationship. Other section of this law enables
the woman to sue her husband to the court. So the same section
should not be employed to declare her non-eligibility.
Women's safety bill in Pakistan : Islamabad
- President Parvez Musharff has passed the bill ( protection
of women ) which was prepared for the protection of the rights
of women in Pakistan, which proved to be controversial and
which under the section 75 was passed in both the houses.
Dr. Niyaj has justified this bill. The women's protection
act has been implemented all over the country. It will be
the same all over the country including border areas. There
will not be any discretion. There will be more laws for the
welfare and protection of women. The prime minister has also
announced that the reservation for women in Gov. Sector will
be increased from the previous 5 % to 10 %.
PMC to provide medical protection to
women from self-help groups - PMC will help by giving Rs.50,000/-
to any women from self help group in Pune if she has a serious
disease. Besides, economic investment will be done in the
name of the daughter of the member who undergoes a family
- planning operation.
In Pune City there are 70000 women members
of the 5000 self help groups. Most of these women are from
economically backward class and if they fall prey to any sickness
like T.B., Cancer or Heart attack or any ailment of uterus,
they are not able to afford the expenses of the medication.
So PMC is to help them. For them, the present budget has a
provision of Rs.25,00,000/-. Treatment will be given in CHS
Hospitals. However, the self help group should be in the PMC
area. It must be registered under the City Improvement Plan.
The group must have completed two years from its formation.
In addition to this, it should function regularly. Women only
from such groups will be benefited by this programme.
In order to boost up family planning
the women from self help groups will be given help by the
PMC. The PMC will invest Rs.10,000/- in the name of the girl
child if the women undergoes family planning surgery.
If the women does this after the birth
of 2 girls, Rs.5,000/- will be invested in the name of each
child. When the girls complete 18 years, they are to get the
money. In order to do this, the present budget will have the
provision of Rs.10,00,000/-. This proposal has been passed
unanimously in the Standing Committee Meeting. The chairman
of the committee, Jayant Bhokare informed the press.
Special facilities for HIV / Aids patients
(Gujarath) - labours migrate on a very large scale from Orissa
to Gujarath in search of work. The % of Aids is increasing
in such labours. To solve this problem, Gujarath Government's,
Gujarath State Aids safety committee has started working all
over the state. The migrated workers stay away for many months
from their home or family. They have to stay at inconvenient
places and this results into the increased in the % of homosexuality.
The problems of hygiene rise. So, in the major cities of Gujarath,
The facilities web camera and internet are available so that
the worker can be in touch with his family. In addition to
this, in order to create awareness regarding health CDs and
booklets are available in oriya language. A lot of voluntary
social organizations have been established. These organizations
have the contact numbers of the doctors who can deal with
the problem of Aids. Entertainment centers have also been
established so that the workers are not attracted towards
dance bars.
Shyia women get the right to Divorce
- In November 2006, All India Shiya Personnel Law Boards implemented
the 'Ideal Nikahnama' which offered shiya woman the right
to divorce her husband. A marriage is to be treated as a legal
contract and comes under the jurisdiction and judgment by
court.
A woman willing to work or study after
her marriage, cannot be prohibited from doing so. If a shiya
woman finds it difficult to follow the bond of marriage then
for divorce she is allowed to access religious leaders. She
can plead to Moulvi - Mulla for divorce.
The ambassadors of Aiyatulla from Iran
and Iraq who function in India can realize divorce. Of course,
this procedure is lengthy.
Before Nikah itself the declaration has
to be signed. In this, the bride has been offered economic
as well as social status.
If the husband does not follow the written
promises, if the contents of the declaration are false or
misguiding and if the wife is deprived of her well being or
right to education then she can plead for her divorce.
If the husband absconding for 2 or more
years, if he is not in touch with his wife, does not care
for her, does not cater to her necessities, if he compels
her to have sexual relationship with other men, she can plead
for her divorce.
Protection against domestic violence
- This bill was passed in 2005 by both the houses and the
concerned act was implemented since 27th October 2006. The
act sought freedom for women from torture or violence may
it be physical, sexual, verbal or psychological.
19705 school girls from UP have established
Meena Manch and have undertaken the task of social awareness.
The organization works in order to prevent child marriage.
Besides necessity of polio doses, persuading more and more
children to primary education and working for cleanliness
are also other tasks.
In Pune, Chaitnya Mahila Mandal from
Budhwar Peth, has started a unique crèche. This is
a crèche which is run during night for the children
of the sex workers from red light area. This profession affects
the children and they are led to crime. This organization
has been working for a year to save the children from this
situation.
The Oxford University College which was
run for 113 years for women only has opened its doors for
men also. The director board, under the leadership of St.
Hilka unanimously decided to admit male students. This was
the only college in London where students, fellows, professors
or guides all were women only.
Due to the insistence from Indians, America
started a school only for girls. There were 90000 schools
but not a single of them was exclusively for girls. Mr. Raju
Natrajan, who has settled down in Seatal contacted the founder
of the National Association for Single Sex, public education,
Dr. Geonie Sax and came to know that in America, in only 6
schools have classrooms specially for girls.
The percentage of heart disease among
women is more than that among men. Every year, 267000 women
die of heart disease. A woman's heart disease becomes problematic
especially when she pregnant. Women who smoke, have diabetes
or take contraceptive pills are likely to have high BP. Compared
to men, the muscles of women's heart are weak. The high or
low percentage of estrogen in women's body may lead to a heart
disease.
The eastern part of Godavari District
is a hilly area and has a deep forest. The adivasi women have
decided to produce electricity from the water falls in these
areas. They are going to sell it to the straight electricity
board. These neglected, poverty stricken women have progressed
on the basis of self help groups.
Bagalcoat in Karnataka has a very high
percentage of Aid's patients. Karnataka health promotion trust
and ICHAP are the two institutes which have undertaken a project
to create Aids free society in order to solve the problem.
As a result of backwardness, lack of medical facilities migrated
labour a large number of devdasies and truck drivers in the
611 villages of Bagalcoat Dist the percentage of HIV positive
patients was phenomenal. To seek the solution to this problem,
doctors, teachers, leaders and social organizations have come
together and for the last four years have been working tirelessly
in order to produce Aids - free villages. Devdasies from these
areas have also helped in this work. They have been helping
themselves by forming self help groups. The unique project
will be a guiding one and an exemplary for the whole country
to be free from aids.
The most important issue of worry today
is aids. The percentage of aids is increasing in soldiers
and it has been affecting their efficiency. Officers are demanding
for the facility of sex education in order to save these soldiers.
In order to realize women's right to
health, since 1975 International Women's Health Conference
is organized. The 10th conference was organized in India.
The following subjects were discussed. (1) The restructuring
of public health section and consideration of women. (2) Women's
rights regarding procreation and sexual health. (3) Policy
regarding population. (4) Modern medical technology and women's
rights. (5) Violence and women's hygiene.
Both the houses as well as the President
have given their consent to the rights of the children bill.
4.5 to 5 lakh girls and boys between
the age of 18 and 35 work in call centers and B.P.O.'s. Most
of them have to work during night shifts. It is observed that,
as a result of this, problems like migraine, loss or memory,
getting irritated by colours, having diseases of years are
becoming common among the youth. The percentage of smoking
and alcoholism is also found to be very high.
Lasent, a medical journal from London
has published a report that violence against woman is rampant
in backward as well as advance countries. The inference was
drawn on the basis of the interviews of 25000 women from 15
places all over the country. It was observed that the agent
of physical and sexual violence was nobody else but the partner
himself. The statistics states that 15 % women from Japan
and 78 % women from the rural Ethiopia tolerate the violence.
300 families living in Andhra Pradesh
on the waters of Godavari rarely come to the ground. Their
whole life is spent on the boat itself. Donullus tribe lives
on fishing. Under the education for all programme, A.P. Government
has started a school in the boats themselves.
The secretary of economic planning department
Montek sing Ahluwalia has suggested the provision of 30 %
amount of government department budgets for women.
Since 1999, Kachh women's development
organization has chosen the community radio for the sake of
the rights of women from Kachh. This is the only available
medium of entertainment in this area and therefore the organization
decided to use this medium effectively. This certainly has
led to social awakening. But in addition to it, certain things
like the women's problems in Kachh, social problems and peoples
expectations are also becoming evident. This radio station
covers 15 lakh people from 950 villages.
Sharmila Irom has been on unending fast
for a last four years to protest against the Armed Forces
Special Power Act implemented in the North- East India. This
law permits the army to kill any suspect terrorist. The innocent
people have to suffer due to this. So, Irom is protesting
against this.
Muslim Mufti (Kazi) from Australia stated
that Muslim Women have to use hijab. He further said that
a woman who does not cover her eyes is like meat kept in the
open. If she were in Hijab, there would not be any problem.
This statement has laid to a controversy in Australia. Besides
the sex discrimination commissioner Gobard stated that absence
of Hizab induces rape.
Netherland has prohibited the Muslim
women from wearing parda. The decision is taken in order to
protect people's safety or security.
Dance Bar : A Major Social Problem
Swati Lele
During 2005-06, banning dance bars became
a controversial issue. There was a lot of discussion in news
papers about it. The Home Minister of Maharashtra, R.R. Patil
took a decision to ban the dance bars which proved to be dangerous
for youth. This decision was appreciated from all strata of
society but the people whose income was lost and those who
were dependent on the dance bars for their survival sought
the help of the court and achieved stay order on banning of
the dance bars. It is necessary to study and analyze the various
angles of the event which has longer lasting effects on society.
In the 90's due to globalization process
there was substantial improvement in the fields of finance
and stock market. On a large scale, people got money. With
the economic progress, the adverse effects of the same could
also be seen on a large scale. Dance bars which had begun
in 80's increased rapidly in the next decade. Had their been
any action taken against these bars by police, income tax
department, Municipal Corporation or leaders, the picture
would have been a different one. Dance bars were established
to channelize black money. Since dance bar lobby became a
resource for money to government system, political leaders
and police departments, these systems or persons could not
heart the lobby.
At present Mumbai has 600 dance bars,
the number of these in small villages is above 650. Many of
these are close to schools, colleges or temples also. More
than 75000 women are involved in this profession. Security
personnels, waitresses, attendance and the people working
in the bar - thousands of them are dependent upon the money
from this profession.
Youth from middle class as well as youth
having easy money traders, agents, corrupt police officers,
people coming to Bombay for business or trade and officers
from big companies who come to Mumbai for official work and
also foreign tourists are attracted to the night life in the
bars go there. People turn to dance bars for entertainment
irrespective of the way they earn their money, it may be through
efforts or loan or it may be through illegal means. The government
gets approximately Rs.1500 crores in the form of tax through
this business. Ms.Sucheta Dalal has argued in an article in
Loksatta that nobody else but the excise department of the
State Government is responsible for the no of dance bars.
Many of these dance bars do not only
remain centers of entertainment but become centers of prostitution
or they are used as pick up points. The girls, working in
the bars are between age group of 14-15 and 25-30. Many of
them have come their through deception or betrayal or for
some of them the retreat is not at all possible.
Many of these have come due to poverty
unemployment or because they have the responsibility of the
family. Some of these have been compelled to carry on this
profession by tradition. Many young educated girls are being
attracted to this glamorous profession which gives easy money
also.
Due to dance bars, the young generation
became addicted to alcohol and drugs. The dire consequences
of addiction, immoral relationships, illegal profession to
gain money for addiction and crime were easily seen. Diseases
like Aids spread very fast. It is then that social reformers
and leaders took serious note of this problem.
However by this time many families have
already been severely affected. Mr. R.R. Patil declared the
bank on 30th August 2005. This was followed by discussions
in the parliament. The opposition parties also supported the
party in power and the bill regarding the ban was passed.
Nevertheless, this led to chaos in society. Through the court,
the dance bar owners and girls sought stay on the order. The
court cancelled the order on the basis of the issue of equality.
The court ordered the stay on the basis of the major section
of the constitution stating that everybody has a right to
income and therefore, dance bars cannot be banned.
An important decision was taken stating that dance and bars
will exist separately. The court opines that the separation
between the loss of mental control due to alcohol and erotic
dance will result into controlling misbehaviour on the part
of the youth.
Resultantly, dance bars were not to be banned. Serving alcohol
is a part of the section regarding hospitality. This does
not include exposing body of a woman but only allows the service
regarding provision of drinks.
So ladies bars were given a permission. It is mandatory for
the owner of the bar to protect the waitresses but can the
woman be safe at such a place were men loose their control
due to excess of alcohol.
Section 14 of the constitution provides
citizens the rights to equality. As a result of this, it is
presumed that the state should treat 5 star hotels, dance
bars, clubs and gyms equally. The state prohibited dance in
bars but it did not do so with the 5 star or 3 star hotels,
clubs or gyms. So this was the breach or rejection of the
principle of equality.
However, the most important issue is
the question of those who exploit or take this advantage of
the helplessness of women. Women have to sell their body or
beauty in order to earn a living. Womanhood is disgraced by
this. The media, influenced by the new economic policies passes
on the message that increase your needs and fulfill them at
any cost and that itself is life.
What after the ban on dance bars? - Maharashtra
is making efforts to ban dance bars but the bill regarding
whether to permit prostitution or not since the government
wants to control aids, is also under consideration.
The State Government has appealed to
the Supreme Court. In spite of the fact that the High Court
cancelled the ban taking into consideration the oppression
and exploitation of women and also the larger social interest.
Before the ban the dance bars were not
only the centers of drunkards but they were the centers of
achieving socio-economic superiority. The owners of the bars
had become very powerful and did not pay any heed to law.
The government understood this and now the government exercises
better control.
Police Officers, employees used to make
attempts to get transferred to such areas and this was resulting
in corruption.
The number of accidents on the express
highway has reduced. Between Jan and August 2005, the number
of fatal accidents was 4 to 4 which included 62 causalities
and 66 injured, 46 serious accidents, 104 minor ones but between
September 2006 to February 2006 the number of fatal accidents
was 180 which included 31 causalities, 18 injured, 25 dead
in serious accidents, 52 injured and 54 minor accidents. This
is the statistics given by Highway Police.
The accidents which used to take place
due to drunkards driving their vehicles rashly also reduced.
The people who lived in the buildings
in which the bar existed or lived in nearby areas, developed
a filling of security due to the ban.
The decision of the ban is very complex
and it leads to various questions :
[1] Whether a bar girl has an opportunity
for employment if she wished to quit
this profession ? [2] Whether the government will provide
education, shelter or means of survival for the children of
the girls so that the children need not continue their mother's
profession ? The government does not have concrete majors
to solve this problem [3] Whether the government is going
to increase the opportunity for employment or education in
the areas from which the girls are brought to the city ? [4]
Can the government resists the unemployed women from coming
to the cities if it cannot give such an opportunity ? [5]
Traditional professions have lost their place in the new social
structure and the new social structure does not contain such
education that will absorb the people who practiced traditional
professions.
There are the various angles of the issue
of the bar girls socio economically backward girls for whom
new means of survival are not available, dancing with the
bar seems to be better than prostitution. They perceive it
as a upward mobility.
The compulsion of the market is such
that one has to sell or bank upon whatever one has and survive.
This formula is accepted unawares.
There are 2 opinions regarding the protest
dance bars : The first opinion which is based on morality
states that nobody should practice immoral behaviour and everybody
should follow that which is respected by the society.
The second opinion which asserts the
need for social development states that everybody has a right
to employment and the right to choose his or her profession.
If a person chooses to work in a bar it is nothing but the
exercise of the person's right. Everybody has a right over
his body and the individual has a freedom to use it the way
he or she wants to use it.
The how come government or society object
? This is an important question.
It is a matter of research to study the
present condition of the unemployed bar girls. Many of these
will take recourse to prostitution. This will certainly result
into serious social and health problems. Many of these girls
have admitted their children in expensive schools but now
they cannot afford the same. Out of the 80 % women bar employees,
the children 30 % are not able to join a school. Some of these
bar girls have migrated to other states. Especially, they
preferred to go to tourist places like Goa as well as countries
like Dubai or Gulf Countries.
One survey brought out that the women
who have left the bar are despised by the society. If they
begin with a new work or job, even the customer or police
ill-treat them. While working as a waitress, male customers
ill-treat them or even they take liberty with them. At work
places also, they have given a bad treatment. The present
number of prostitutes in India is depressing. There are 40
lakhs prostitutes in India and 35 % of them belong to the
age between 12 and 15. This statistics was published by national
woman and child welfare committee.
This problem is very serious. One does
not feel that dance bars should be there but the result of
the ban is also horrifying and has new serious problems accompanying
it. The route of the problem must be reached. We will have
to work step by step starting from ban on alcohol consumption,
employment generation, moral education and the male mind set.
The government and voluntary organization will have to work
jointly. Political will is also essential. Banning dance bars
is only an easy and superficial solution.
Only 15 % women in total employment
: Though women work equally with men, their percentage
is low i.e. only 14.7 %. 44 Lac women work in public sector
as well as private industry. 1,18,000 are labourers. 17,34,000
are women workers.
Indian Military and Women
Asha Bapat
Sushmita Chakravati an officer in the
Indian Army committed suicide on 15th Jan 2006. Sushmita was
very much disappointed to see that there was disparity between
what she had learnt and what she had to do as an officer in
military. She committed suicide due to this frustration. After
this, there began a discussion whether women should be employed
in military. Moreover, the army general Mr. Pattabhiraman's
statement that army can survive without women added a lot
of different angles to the discussion. Against this background,
the Central Home Minister, Mr. Pranav Mukherji presented a
very positive view regarding having women in the military.
He also explained that women will be motivated to join military
and they will be provided various facilities and creation
of favorable conditions will be given emphasis. Military has
undertaken a study in order to employ women in military as
well as to create proper atmosphere. AFMC has studied and
given a proof that regarding the work in military, women and
men have been working with equal efficiency.
The Air Force is studying. So that they
are able to change the design of the fighter crafts. There
was a lot of discussion in the newspapers and special articles
regarding the subject.
The following statistics shows the %
of women in military.
Indian Army
34000 Officers
933 women officers
2.7 %
Navy - Total 7000 officers
100 women officers
1.4 %
Air Force
Total 10200 officers
400 women officers
4.4 %.
At present women get employment in the
military through short service commission and are allowed
to work only for 14 years. They are not able to reach the
position of Major. In Indian Army, women are allowed to work
only in non combatant wings which means that they have to
work in the departments which are not directly concerned with
war. The departments include the engineering, ordnance, intelligence,
communication, medical, education, law, logistics and air
traffic control depts. Women are not appointed for Tanks,
Weapons, Submarines or fighter ships.
In his article, Rajveer Williams has
discussed whether women should enter this field. The decision
to employ women in military services was taken before 13 years
it self by an able board of officers. So, according to Williams,
it need not be examined again. The board has then only taken
in to consideration the status and position of women and the
over all Indian perspective regarding women.
Women's Physical & Psychological
condition should be examined before employing them in the
military. According to Williams, work other than actually
fighting in the war is also equally important because most
of this work is a team work. Women can be employed in various
wings so that conducive conditions for fighting and winning
a war can be created. These departments may include communication,
intelligence, medicine and psychological operation. Military
training should be given to men and women simultaneously and
jointly. This will change the atmosphere at work place. Even
reservations and objections regarding women will reduce. Williams
asserts the necessity to change the mindset.
Most of the countries including India
seem not to be very enthusiastic in sending women to fight
directly. Of course, the major reason for this is the in human
torture that they may have to face.
While considering the question as to
why women are required in military, it became quite clear
that the military itself reflected the direct picture of our
society. If women are seen in all the fields of society, then
why not in military ? Though it is necessary to change the
perspective of men towards women, women agreed to respectable
and friendly treatment meted out to them by some male officers.
Women's complaints are basically regarding the less practice
in training as compared to i.e. given to men and trivial jobs
that women are given and also the male attitude. Women do
not want discrimination in the treatment while training or
actually working. They are ready stand shoulder to shoulder
with men and they are also ready to put in hard work equally.
Till today, women were admitted in the military through women's
special army school. But now this facility is removed. Now
they will have to enter military like their male colleagues
through short service commission.
Military life is hard. Even men find
it difficult to persevere then women of course, may find it
more difficult to do so. Even men are not able to bear less
slip, hard work, tiredness and mental vacuum. Men persevere
with the help of each others company. However, women's case
will be different. Being a women and an officer she has to
follow the military discipline and cannot try to befriend
soldiers and other officers. Some opine that this leads to
more loneliness and it becomes difficult to adjust.
There is discrimination in the salary
given to a male and a female officer working in the same authority
or position. Women do not get pension after retirement and
since their age is 36 after the service of 14 years, they
are not eligible for government jobs. Men generally become
security guards but women are not able to do it. After having
observed this the demand to allow women to work in military
for some more years, is increasing.
Men in military also have certain complaints
against women's admission in military. Basically, in a patriarchal
society, receiving orders from the female officer is a bit
difficult. Besides, military has very less peace positions
and if these are given to women then men will have less no
of positions and this is injustice according to them.
Women officers were sent on fighter ship
in the sea but due to practical and operational problems they
were asked to come back. There is confusion regarding this
problem all over the world. Women were employed in the Air
Force since 1992. They work in helicopters and goods transport
departments. Since 1993 America employed women in fighter
aircrafts. Australia has decided to send women soldiers on
missions due to scarcity of soldiers in military. Israil is
one such country were women participate directly in war. Pakistan
has more than 4000 women in military. Still this percentage
is only 1%. Women began with medical services and they have
also sought the position of paratroopers, jet pilots and now
some of them have become Generals also. Recently 4 women have
been employed as pilots in Air Force.
During the last few years girls from
various cities of Maharashtra are making efforts to become
military officers this year Madhura, Sneha and Tanmaya from
Navi Mumbai and Thane have joined the Air Force. Vahida prism
proved to be the first women officer in the history of Indian
Military to lead march past. Anuja Varudkar, Aboli Deshpande,
Suchitra Navale and Sumalata Nagraj from Pune have joined
army. India felicitated Noor Inayat who fought against Nazis
during the second world war. Her memorial has been erected
near Paris.
In spite of all this the issue is controversial.
The president of American social congress and the famous radical
feminist Dr. Betty Friedan has raised a very different issue
in her article. She has protested against women entering military
and has asked ' should mothers be killers' ? According to
her, the human culture began to develop since women stopped
hunting in ancient times itself. Then family system came into
existence. Should they again turn to hunting ? But in India
women have been at the top positions since the age of Puranas
and Vedas.
It will be apt to mention the following
reference while discussing women's entry into the military
field.
' Subhaschandra Bose ' opined that the Azad Hind Sena will
remain incomplete if women do not join it.
Introduction to Some Inspiring Institutions
They also want to live happily : Bhagini
Nivedita Pratisthan from Sangli has started a children's home
for the children who are suffering from aids and are fighting
against death. This is the first of its kind in Asia. At present
there are 28 children. The government provides financial help
for them. The institute provides education also. But such
children need love. It is in our hands to bring happiness
in the short lives of these children.
Nasim Sheikh - 9822013186 - 2373273.
Self confidence in spite of being HIV
positive - Kousalya from a small village in Tamilnadu, who
herself is an Aids patient has not collapsed psychologically
and has been vigorously supporting women suffering from aids.
Frustration does not touch her and she has formed Positive
Women's Network for women like her. The institute has undertaken
many programs like counseling for the aids patients, their
medication, providing nutritious food, seeking justice for
them and creating social awareness. She not only voices before
UNO the grievances of the women suffering from aids but also
before institutions in India as well as foreign countries
and travels in other countries for the mission of controlling
aids. Kausalya did her schooling only till 8th standard and
became an aids patient due to her husband but her perseverance
and her will to help others survive are certainly inspiring.
Efforts only for living with self respect
- In the border areas of Maharashtra & Karnataka the percentage
of Devdasies is very high. Dr. Bhimrao Gasti has been making
efforts for the last 30 years so that these Devdasies develop
themselves and get education in order to live independently.
The institution Utthan which works for the resurrection of
Devdasies, functions at Karve, Chandgad, Dist - Kolhapur.
There are hostels and vocational training classes for enabling
the Devdasies to live a normal life like other women and also
enabling their children to live with self respect.
Gautamnagar - Gautamnagar in Chandrapur
is a small residential area of 25 houses. Nobody was allowed
to enter this village which has a criminal background and
red light area. But Praveen Hivre, with the help of Maharashtra
Aids Control Society brought about a sea change in the village.
For the first time in the village, free information regarding
HIV, condom and medical services are made available. Wine
shops were closed. Prostitutes formed self-help groups due
to the efforts made by the institute. The women in the society
got employment and attempts to free them forever from prostitution
are also made by Noble Education Society.
|